klswoot


quality posts: 0 Private Messages klswoot
Re: Boyhood Dream



Love this! And the colors. Wish it was a tad bigger. Can you post a bigger picture. Great work!

tgentry


quality posts: 105 Private Messages tgentry

Staff

klswoot wrote:
I don't have a problem with them being used if they are used in an original way so that the end result is a design that hasn't been done before.



I agree it should be a unique design and also the designer should be up front about it being clip art. People were complimenting him on his style and he even mentioned drawing and scanning etc... I think we were all led to believe this was hand drawn, which is not very cool.

klswoot


quality posts: 0 Private Messages klswoot
cheesesandwich wrote:Well, I just got home from work and read through the copious amounts of comments on my shirt page. All I can really say is... "WOW!" I always expect people to say negative things in the forum... some constructive and some not. What I am surprised at is when somebody (anybody) takes their dislike for a particular shirt, and turns it in to an opportunity to insult someone (or an entire forum of people) personally.

I really and truly respect the fact that everyone has an opinion and the right to share it, but throwing around put-downs and insults is not really expressing an opinion, it's just unnecessary. When I don't like shirts, I just don't vote for them I may offer constructive criticism (mostly when asked), but I do not lash out and question/judge/insult the designer's skills, physique, political views, sexual orientation or otherwise. I just don't get it.

It's a shirt with cupcakes growing from a tree, it's brightly colored, it's supposed to be fun and/or funny. It shouldn't be the center of a rage filled debate. At the end of the derby, either people voted for it or they didn't, none of this back and forth will really matter.

I am always pleased and grateful to win or be printed (this week would be no exception), but if it doesn't happen I am fine with that. I always just figure it means that not enough people liked the shirt, nothing personal, just didn't like it. That said, it's nice to see as many positive posts and notes as negative ones. It probably all balances out in the end!



Cheese your a class act. For that reason, I will buy your shirt if you win. I voted for it, but wasn't sold on it until your most polite reply to the critics. Well said!

eyeslikesugar


quality posts: 2 Private Messages eyeslikesugar
klswoot wrote:Cheese your a class act. For that reason, I will buy your shirt if you win. I voted for it, but wasn't sold on it until your most polite reply to the critics. Well said!



Well-said, cheese. And very true, kls.

=)

-James Cho -EdgarRMcherly Shirt.Woot.Com - Ye Oldest Sucker - 2009

akliens


quality posts: 0 Private Messages akliens

arg!

Hulk Smash!

cheesesandwich


quality posts: 0 Private Messages cheesesandwich
klswoot wrote:Cheese your a class act. For that reason, I will buy your shirt if you win. I voted for it, but wasn't sold on it until your most polite reply to the critics. Well said!



Oh, wow, thanks KLS! For what it's worth, I really meant every word.

cheesesandwich


quality posts: 0 Private Messages cheesesandwich
eyeslikesugar wrote:Well-said, cheese. And very true, kls.

=)



Thanks e.l.s. I have appreciated your kind words this week!

Fallen4Love


quality posts: 0 Private Messages Fallen4Love
Re: Tormented Dreams



i like it

sigaru


quality posts: 0 Private Messages sigaru

not quite obviously dream related, but i kinda like the design anyways.

jbedwar1


quality posts: 0 Private Messages jbedwar1
klswoot wrote:Cheese your a class act. For that reason, I will buy your shirt if you win. I voted for it, but wasn't sold on it until your most polite reply to the critics. Well said!



Got my vote now as well

BIZZEL


quality posts: 0 Private Messages BIZZEL
dmband364142 wrote:focused on the bad things in life...
money, cars, possessions.

...just my input.



LOL that is true but hey it makes for a cool shirt.

sigaru


quality posts: 0 Private Messages sigaru
Re: Ocean R.E.M.



i love this one! i really hope it goes for sale, i'd definitely buy one!

and, at least one person already said it, but the octopus only has seven legs. lol, i just noticed that. not that there is anything wrong, it's still amazing!

cheesesandwich


quality posts: 0 Private Messages cheesesandwich
jbedwar1 wrote:Got my vote now as well



thanks dude!

snarkygal


quality posts: 4 Private Messages snarkygal
lanpartyz wrote:I was spinning off the term "Pipe Dream". Look closely and you will see pipes unless you truely are dense



That was uncalled for. And your title is correct. It is Ugly.

klswoot


quality posts: 0 Private Messages klswoot
Re: Sleeping Problems



I love this design. Very cute, fun and super creative. Glad to see that the voters agree. Congratulations on your quick rise to the top!

ElectricFever


quality posts: 0 Private Messages ElectricFever
Re: Cats fly in dreams with wings...



:3 I love kitties. Sorry to see this one go and yah the judging is kind of weird, but it doesn't mean it's a bad design. I really like the colors and swooshy blue things in the bg.

(btw I have been rejected for designing a "violent" shirt when apparently zombies with brains showing and bones with meats showing isn't as violent stay in derbies) (my shirt was just someone getting punched in the face very cartoony but eh.)

snarkygal


quality posts: 4 Private Messages snarkygal
cheesesandwich wrote:Well, I just got home from work and read through the copious amounts of comments on my shirt page. All I can really say is... "WOW!" I always expect people to say negative things in the forum... some constructive and some not. What I am surprised at is when somebody (anybody) takes their dislike for a particular shirt, and turns it in to an opportunity to insult someone (or an entire forum of people) personally.

I really and truly respect the fact that everyone has an opinion and the right to share it, but throwing around put-downs and insults is not really expressing an opinion, it's just unnecessary. When I don't like shirts, I just don't vote for them I may offer constructive criticism (mostly when asked), but I do not lash out and question/judge/insult the designer's skills, physique, political views, sexual orientation or otherwise. I just don't get it.

It's a shirt with cupcakes growing from a tree, it's brightly colored, it's supposed to be fun and/or funny. It shouldn't be the center of a rage filled debate. At the end of the derby, either people voted for it or they didn't, none of this back and forth will really matter.

I am always pleased and grateful to win or be printed (this week would be no exception), but if it doesn't happen I am fine with that. I always just figure it means that not enough people liked the shirt, nothing personal, just didn't like it. That said, it's nice to see as many positive posts and notes as negative ones. It probably all balances out in the end!



Cheese, you are awesome. A truly classy lady!

eyeslikesugar


quality posts: 2 Private Messages eyeslikesugar
snarkygal wrote:That was uncalled for. And your title is correct. It is Ugly.



Yep. Very rude. And because of such a rude comment, I'm going to leave one, too: it's been done to death and still available for purchase! Try again.

-James Cho -EdgarRMcherly Shirt.Woot.Com - Ye Oldest Sucker - 2009

cheesesandwich


quality posts: 0 Private Messages cheesesandwich
snarkygal wrote:Cheese, you are awesome. A truly classy lady!



Thanks, snarky. I really appreciate you saying (typing) that.

ElectricFever


quality posts: 0 Private Messages ElectricFever
Re: When Hippos Dream..



Rejected for not changing enough? Wow that sucks. I thought you changed a lot of it as well. Oh well... :3 I really like the sad faces lol makes me feel bad for the poor hippos.

ElectricFever


quality posts: 0 Private Messages ElectricFever
Re: Clown Fish



:3 cute!

ElectricFever


quality posts: 0 Private Messages ElectricFever
Re: Nerd No more



Lol I loved this one. People need to embrace their nerdy self and vote! I know you wow players are out there! Needs more loven! LFG Nerd No More!

ElectricFever


quality posts: 0 Private Messages ElectricFever
Re: floating rabbits



I like this. The white outline of the face is my fav part.

ElectricFever


quality posts: 0 Private Messages ElectricFever
Re: Restless Night



:3 your textures make me happy.

fablefire


quality posts: 15 Private Messages fablefire
Re: Sweet Dreams Are Made of These...



Lawl... they're the cupcakes of rage! CUPCAKE ARMAGEDDON!!! :O

ElectricFever


quality posts: 0 Private Messages ElectricFever
Re: Dream at Night



I like this one too. The thumb nail doesn't do it justice I almost over looked it. It's well drawn and clean :3 vote.

ElectricFever


quality posts: 0 Private Messages ElectricFever
ElectricFever wrote:I like this one too. The thumb nail doesn't do it justice I almost over looked it. It's well drawn and clean :3 vote.



dog is cute at the end of the bed too lol

ElectricFever


quality posts: 0 Private Messages ElectricFever
Re: I Want To Be An Astronaut



:3 could you put it on a shirt so we can see? I'm fond of your drawing.

cheesesandwich


quality posts: 0 Private Messages cheesesandwich
fablefire wrote:Lawl... they're the cupcakes of rage! CUPCAKE ARMAGEDDON!!! :O



Those aren't cupcakes, those are battle-bots trained to kill the enemy.

tgentry


quality posts: 105 Private Messages tgentry

Staff

sigaru wrote:i love this one! i really hope it goes for sale, i'd definitely buy one!

and, at least one person already said it, but the octopus only has seven legs. lol, i just noticed that. not that there is anything wrong, it's still amazing!



Thanks! Yeah it was a trade-off. Add the final leg and clutter up the design or leave it off and have people point out there's only 7. I figured most people that see it on the street wouldn't count them, but they would notice it was kind of cluttered looking. It was the lesser of two evils I think.

cyberpenguin


quality posts: 9 Private Messages cyberpenguin
tgentry wrote:Where was this four days ago?!? I really want this shirt! Argh.



I'll second that.

Josephus


quality posts: 25 Private Messages Josephus
tgentry wrote:Thanks! Yeah it was a trade-off. Add the final leg and clutter up the design or leave it off and have people point out there's only 7. I figured most people that see it on the street wouldn't count them, but they would notice it was kind of cluttered looking. It was the lesser of two evils I think.


did you consider adding it, but in a really dark color, quite close to the shirt color?

sokowa


quality posts: 3 Private Messages sokowa
klswoot wrote:I love this design. Very cute, fun and super creative. Glad to see that the voters agree. Congratulations on your quick rise to the top!



Indeed! This is all very humbling. It was a lot of fun drawing (couldn't help smiling at the little buggers) hopefully others feel the same. It's one of the precious few drawings that just seemed to draw themselves
Thanks!

tgentry


quality posts: 105 Private Messages tgentry

Staff

Josephus wrote:did you consider adding it, but in a really dark color, quite close to the shirt color?



I'm sure if I fooled around with it for a while I could work it in somewhere, but I settled on the 7 and I'll stand by it. It's a dream after all. Things are weird in dreams! 7 is a lucky number.

Josephus


quality posts: 25 Private Messages Josephus
tgentry wrote:I'm sure if I fooled around with it for a while I could work it in somewhere, but I settled on the 7 and I'll stand by it. It's a dream after all. Things are weird in dreams! 7 is a lucky number.



I just assumed that it was hidden behind the rest. I don't think you really need to defend it. Now if it were a sheep with only 3 legs, that might be something to argue with ;^)

kazzmonkey


quality posts: 0 Private Messages kazzmonkey
Re: A Dream of High Performance



Cute! Reminds me of things I used to draw.

ElectricFever


quality posts: 0 Private Messages ElectricFever
Re: Sweet Dreams Are Made of These...



Lordy. I tried to read all the comments on here to see what all the hub bub was about, but I felt my soul dying from all the wah babies.

The colors are awesome I love sprinkles on my cup cakes. Love the song. The layout is really nice. I like the size. I think you are made of magic.

kazzmonkey


quality posts: 0 Private Messages kazzmonkey
Re: What Dreams Are Made Of



I really like this. The placement is interesting and the detail/colors very appealing.

kazzmonkey


quality posts: 0 Private Messages kazzmonkey
Re: What Dreams Are Made Of



Oop, sorry, forgot to say that I think the placement might be made slightly better if the boy was lower, like toward the bottom of the shirt, while the "dream" remained where it is. Just to spread it out a bit more.

kazzmonkey


quality posts: 0 Private Messages kazzmonkey
Re: Boyhood Dream



I wish this was submitted earlier. I also wish it was bigger. Its hard to get all the details when its so small.