HAH...
dear god...
Okay, please, at the very least, do not decide to hate another design because a design you liked got thrown out. Yes, it's sort of obvious that sour grapes are driving the arguments to throw it out. It takes away any weight from your already lightweight arguments.
This is a really great design, and the positive points here are what matters. People like the design, they will buy the shirt, and it fits the rules as much as any of the designs.
Good job, guys.