Derby #200: The Silver Screen

Here's lookin' at you silver screen...

Thumbnail doesn't match detail image

Rejected because: Thumbnail doesn't match detail image

add a comment

Comments

jcaplow


quality posts: 0 Private Messages jcaplow

So is that what Rick meant by "kid"? Real classy.

kevincrimi


quality posts: 0 Private Messages kevincrimi
Re: Here's lookin' at you silver screen...


Just for clarification, did this get rejected because it has the entire shirt in the thumbnail or because the two goats are separated?

I just ask because a lot of the designs will add in "vote" or "click" into the thumbnail which technically, makes those different than the shirt design as well.


Check out my Derby Shirt!

sasham62


quality posts: 0 Private Messages sasham62


kevincrimi wrote:Just for clarification, did this get rejected because it has the entire shirt in the thumbnail or because the two goats are separated?

I just ask because a lot of the designs will add in "vote" or "click" into the thumbnail which technically, makes those different than the shirt design as well.


I think the problem here is that the thumbnail (aka design detail) looks like a navy or black T-shirt who's design features a goat and a pig (?) with a balloon looking at a silver T-shirt with a goat, a pig and a balloon. You would have been better served with the design detail thumbnail showing the detail of the design, and using what you *did* use as a design detail thumbnail as your shirt comp.

blinddog3d


quality posts: 0 Private Messages blinddog3d
kevincrimi wrote:Just for clarification, did this get rejected because it has the entire shirt in the thumbnail or because the two goats are separated?

I just ask because a lot of the designs will add in "vote" or "click" into the thumbnail which technically, makes those different than the shirt design as well.


This got rejected because the essence of the design is different in the two visual offerings. It looks like there is a baloon on the aleeve and in one they are apart & the other is close. The viewre can't be sure which is the actual design.

Woot views this as deceptive or a "bait & switch." In the comp, you need to show; the design orientation on the shirt in the actual shirt color, what the gradient halftones look like and ant details you want to show off. The detail can be anything from the design, but it can't be different than the Big Picture."

Hope this helped.
BlindDog3D

ecpage


quality posts: 0 Private Messages ecpage
blinddog3d wrote:This got rejected because the essence of the design is different in the two visual offerings. It looks like there is a baloon on the aleeve and in one they are apart & the other is close. The viewre can't be sure which is the actual design.

Woot views this as deceptive or a "bait & switch." In the comp, you need to show; the design orientation on the shirt in the actual shirt color, what the gradient halftones look like and ant details you want to show off. The detail can be anything from the design, but it can't be different than the Big Picture."

Hope this helped.
BlindDog3D


That is so dumb. There is clearly a shirt that illustrates what the design is. The creator obviously just didn't like the empty space at the bottom and simply filled it in with the two characters from the t-shirt. Is this really that complicated that someone might not be able figure out what's going to be on the shirt???

More Derby Entries

By date:

By rank:

Thumbnail