Derby #29: Trompe L'Oeil

Operation

Already done at Threadless

Rejected because: Already done at Threadless

add a comment

Comments

keyser520


quality posts: 0 Private Messages keyser520
Re: Operation

and this is the last one i have time to make...heading out of town

tgentry


quality posts: 105 Private Messages tgentry

Staff

keyser520 wrote:and this is the last one i have time to make...heading out of town


Someone already posted this Threadless shirt.

keyser520


quality posts: 0 Private Messages keyser520
tgentry wrote:Someone already posted this Threadless shirt.


you've gotta be kidding me....

I did a google shirt for "operation tee shirt" and did a threadless shirt for "operation" and the only thing I found was a no longer available shirt in the google search... couldn't find any actively being sold ANYWHERE.

I give up... my two best ideas this week were already done somewhere else...

So much for today's work...sigh...

*cries*

bluchez


quality posts: 2 Private Messages bluchez
keyser520 wrote:you've gotta be kidding me....

I give up... my two best ideas this week were already done somewhere else?

*cries*


geekfactor was being exceptionally nice, and tried to help prevent this by posting a bunch of them that she found, they are on page 1 of the derby forum. Make sure you consult before idea 3.

AdderXYU


quality posts: 38 Private Messages AdderXYU
tgentry wrote:Someone already posted this Threadless shirt.


I'd duck and cover, Tgent. daring to imply that a shirt was printed elsewhere will set off the loonies.

Though really, this is incredibly blatant, in ways even Rob isn't. This isn't even similar concept, this is almost the exact same shirt. And it's not like it's a matter of never browsing threadless this week, either. A number of shirts are near identical to shirts posted at the beginning of this derby's thread.

keyser520


quality posts: 0 Private Messages keyser520
bluchez wrote:geekfactor was being exceptionally nice, and tried to help prevent this by posting a bunch of them that she found, they are on page 1 of the derby forum. Make sure you consult before idea 3.

This was idea 3, actually... but there is no idea 4 for me. I have to head out of town. Won't be back until Monday....and that will be too late for more entries.



keyser520


quality posts: 0 Private Messages keyser520
bluchez wrote:geekfactor was being exceptionally nice, and tried to help prevent this by posting a bunch of them that she found, they are on page 1 of the derby forum. Make sure you consult before idea 3.

Idid a google search for "operation tee shirt" and a threadless shirt for "operation" before designing this one... couldn't find em.. I then did a search for "opeartion the game" and used the real game as a basis for making my vectors, so I'd have at least something similar to the original game pieces as far as looks go. The shadows were from making a inner/outer shadow filter, merging it with another layer to get the filter off, then deleting the non shadow parts from the new layer.

geekfactor12


quality posts: 11 Private Messages geekfactor12
keyser520 wrote:Idid a google search for "operation tee shirt" and a threadless shirt for "operation" before designing this one... couldn't find em.. I then did a search for "opeartion the game" and used the real game as a basis for making my vectors, so I'd have at least something similar to the original game pieces as far as looks go. The shadows were from making a inner/outer shadow filter, merging it with another layer to get the filter off, then deleting the non shadow parts from the new layer.


Really? Because I googled Threadless Operation Shirt and it was the first result. You need to work on your google-fu, my friend.

JadenKale


quality posts: 162 Private Messages JadenKale
geekfactor12 wrote:Really? Because I googled Threadless Operation Shirt and it was the first result. You need to work on your google-fu, my friend.


yeah it's also shown on a guy and a baby on the 1st page of pictures if you just type "operation shirt" Sorry Keyser.

bluchez


quality posts: 2 Private Messages bluchez
geekfactor12 wrote:Really? Because I googled Threadless Operation Shirt and it was the first result. You need to work on your google-fu, my friend.


hmm, google of "operation tee shirt" works too.

keyser520


quality posts: 0 Private Messages keyser520
geekfactor12 wrote:Really? Because I googled Threadless Operation Shirt and it was the first result. You need to work on your google-fu, my friend.


I googled "operation tee shirt" and then i went to threadless and did a catologue search for "operation". I'll try your approach next time.

Oh well.... so much for this week.

Buy all.

keyser520


quality posts: 0 Private Messages keyser520
bluchez wrote:hmm, google of "operation tee shirt" works too.


yeah...that finds the one result that i found... but that was a shir tthat is NO LONGER available.... thus I thought it wouldn't count as "being sold elsewhere"

bluchez


quality posts: 2 Private Messages bluchez
keyser520 wrote:yeah...that finds the one result that i found... but that was a shir tthat is NO LONGER available.... thus I thought it wouldn't count as "being sold elsewhere"


still shows for sale for me? who knows. gl finding time for your next idea.

Andy47240


quality posts: 0 Private Messages Andy47240
bluchez wrote:still shows for sale for me? who knows. gl finding time for your next idea.

Whoever prints it, it is a cool shirt.



techminion


quality posts: 0 Private Messages techminion
Re: Operation


This shirt idea is awesome!

AdderXYU


quality posts: 38 Private Messages AdderXYU
techminion wrote:This shirt idea is awesome!


So awesome threadless is nearly sold out

komiks


quality posts: 0 Private Messages komiks

I could've sworn I've seen this before and turns out I was right.
http://www.threadless.com/product/285/Operation_Needed
Are you the artist that did that?

Discobiscuits


quality posts: 1 Private Messages Discobiscuits
Re: Operation


:\ Near replica of the Threadless t-shirt. Too bad, I would've picked this one up definitely.

kriscad


quality posts: 0 Private Messages kriscad
Re: Operation


be cool if they can print this right

keyser520


quality posts: 0 Private Messages keyser520
Re: Operation


Nope...wasn't me that did those others. As I said, I didn't find 'em when I did my search, but apparently I suck at searching for shirts on threadless.... I assumed that typing in "operation" in their catologue search was what I needed to do to see if it was out there. I was wrong..


Alas... I did have a LONG drive today (8 hours bcz of traffic.. should have taken 5). ANd now I must sleep.

Hopey


quality posts: 0 Private Messages Hopey
keyser520 wrote:Nope...wasn't me that did those others. As I said, I didn't find 'em when I did my search, but apparently I suck at searching for shirts on threadless....


Since "your" design is almost identical to this I'd say you are pretty good at searching for shirts on Threadless, and then copying them.

I look forward to your "Vote For Pedro" design someday.

brizz


quality posts: 0 Private Messages brizz
kriscad wrote:be cool if they can print this right


Do you people just not read anything? how is this still atop the hotness when it's a blatant plagiarism of a threadless shirt that is still for sale?!??!?!

brizz


quality posts: 0 Private Messages brizz
keyser520 wrote:you've gotta be kidding me....

I did a google shirt for "operation tee shirt" and did a threadless shirt for "operation" and the only thing I found was a no longer available shirt in the google search... couldn't find any actively being sold ANYWHERE.


i believe you googled operation tee shirt, because the threadless shirt is the first link that comes up! It's even the same color...same four pieces in the same position...come on man...just terrible.

superspryte


quality posts: 21 Private Messages superspryte

Volunteer Moderator

Hopey wrote:Since "your" design is almost identical to this I'd say you are pretty good at searching for shirts on Threadless, and then copying them.

I look forward to your "Vote For Pedro" design someday.


Guys, enough with the "this is blatantly copied" and all of that. We got it, threadless has it. ^_~ It's going to get rejected. Again, we got that.

Something else to consider is the actual game. If I made a shirt like this it would end up looking a lot like either one, because the game looks like this:

It is actually possible that an image of the game pieces were traced and not the other shirt. In fact, now you can say that they're both unoriginal if you prefer. But please, lay off a little. Please? There are subtle differences which make me think that it is not simply traced, like the shape and layout of the wishbone. Don't get me wrong, I believe it will and should be rejected, but give Kesney a break, guys. These things happen.

@Keyser - I'm a culprit of this too because I wubble wasting designs, but you may want to take this down. If nothing else, you can take it down once it's rejected, assuming it hasn't been more than 24 hours (if anyone doens't know, that's what the little red X in the corner is. ^_~). I also think I figured out why you didn't find the threadless shirts. I was looking for examples of the game and Googled "operation game" and it only came up with that unavailable shirt, which was on the second page. Next time try a little harder or ask the forums, 'kay? If it exists, they'll usually know. It would've saved you tons of time too. ^_^

w: 6 | s.w: 14 | so.w: 2 | t.w: 1 | w.w: 15

geekfactor12


quality posts: 11 Private Messages geekfactor12
keyser520 wrote:Nope...wasn't me that did those others. As I said, I didn't find 'em when I did my search, but apparently I suck at searching for shirts on threadless.... I assumed that typing in "operation" in their catologue search was what I needed to do to see if it was out there. I was wrong..


Not to be a I wuvs you!, but... typing operation in the catalog search brought up that shirt as a result with no problem.

uhland


quality posts: 0 Private Messages uhland
Re: Operation


ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient
ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient
ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient

The only shirt I would buy and its rejected.
Its a good shirt. Wittle teeny foo-foo

geekfactor12


quality posts: 11 Private Messages geekfactor12
uhland wrote:ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient
ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient
ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient ebullient

The only shirt I would buy and its rejected.
Its a good shirt. Wittle teeny foo-foo


It's rejected because you can already buy it. At Threadless.

Discobiscuits


quality posts: 1 Private Messages Discobiscuits
geekfactor12 wrote:It's rejected because you can already buy it. At Threadless.


It's like sold out now cuz of the shirt design on woot, XD

keyser520


quality posts: 0 Private Messages keyser520
superspryte wrote:Guys, enough with the "this is blatantly copied" and all of that. We got it, threadless has it. ^_~ It's going to get rejected. Again, we got that.

Something else to consider is the actual game. If I made a shirt like this it would end up looking a lot like either one, because the game looks like this:

It is actually possible that an image of the game pieces were traced and not the other shirt. In fact, now you can say that they're both unoriginal if you prefer. But please, lay off a little. Please? There are subtle differences which make me think that it is not simply traced, like the shape and layout of the wishbone. Don't get me wrong, I believe it will and should be rejected, but give Kesney a break, guys. These things happen.

@Keyser - I'm a culprit of this too because I wubble wasting designs, but you may want to take this down. If nothing else, you can take it down once it's rejected, assuming it hasn't been more than 24 hours (if anyone doens't know, that's what the little red X in the corner is. ^_~). I also think I figured out why you didn't find the threadless shirts. I was looking for examples of the game and Googled "operation game" and it only came up with that unavailable shirt, which was on the second page. Next time try a little harder or ask the forums, 'kay? If it exists, they'll usually know. It would've saved you tons of time too. ^_^


Thanks. I really would wubble to be accused of stealing shirt designs, because it's a really silly thing to do... obviously, someone is going to find the design and then it will get rejected. Unfortunately, for me, both of my "best" designs this derby were ones that had already been implemented... the Inigo Montoya one was done, slightly diferently, and the operation one was done pretty darn close to the same way. I was headed out of town Friday at 4, and had just had the Inigo shirt rejected. I had a coulpe ideas of a shirt to do, but all of them would have taken far more than the 3 hours I had left. I went to lunch and had the operation idea hit me, and came back to make the shirt. Unfortunately, I didn't find it when I did the search. It's quite frustrating... but, alas... that's life.

Anyways, I've had a great weekend teaching a dance workshop, and I'll see you all next Friday at noon :-)

More Derby Entries

By date:

By rank:

Thumbnail