Derby #252: Three's a Crowd

Goodby Piglet

Nope, can't do it.

Rejected because: Nope, can't do it.

add a comment

Comments

plainyoghurt


quality posts: 0 Private Messages plainyoghurt
Re: Goodby Piglet


Spend hours working on a design and then spell the title incorrectly. Fantastic.

So, anyone care to place a bet as to how quickly the rejectionifier will do its thing on this? Still, fun to do regardless.

ciaralee


quality posts: 2 Private Messages ciaralee
Re: Goodby Piglet


Why??

plainyoghurt


quality posts: 0 Private Messages plainyoghurt
ciaralee wrote:Why??


I have this nasty feeling that the copyright for winnie the pooh is held by Disney.

orabbit


quality posts: 29 Private Messages orabbit
plainyoghurt wrote:I have this nasty feeling that the copyright for winnie the pooh is held by Disney.


I think they meant why does this image exist? What are you trying to say here? Why would Pooh grind up his buddy in the garbage disposal, and how does this relate to the theme?

plainyoghurt


quality posts: 0 Private Messages plainyoghurt
orabbit wrote:I think they meant why does this image exist? What are you trying to say here? Why would Pooh grind up his buddy in the garbage disposal, and how does this relate to the theme?


Oh, I see. Pooh would grind up his buddy in the garbage disposal to be the sole recipient of christopher robins affections.

msgmissy


quality posts: 1 Private Messages msgmissy
plainyoghurt wrote:I have this nasty feeling that the copyright for winnie the pooh is held by Disney.


Yes.

And also:

Not kid-friendly or tasteful.

And also:

Not on theme. Off topic.

plainyoghurt


quality posts: 0 Private Messages plainyoghurt
msgmissy wrote:Yes.

And also:

Not kid-friendly or tasteful.

And also:

Not on theme. Off topic.


Is "kid friendly" and "tasteful" part of the submission criteria?

And also: It is on theme. Christopher Robin + Pooh + Piglet = 3 which is a crowd. And having established this pooh has decided to off piglet. Although I will concede that without Christoper Robin actually in the frame somehow, the message is a bit... Muddled.

misstracee


quality posts: 0 Private Messages misstracee
plainyoghurt wrote:Is "kid friendly" and "tasteful" part of the submission criteria?

And also: It is on theme. Christopher Robin + Pooh + Piglet = 3 which is a crowd. And having established this pooh has decided to off piglet. Although I will concede that without Christoper Robin actually in the frame somehow, the message is a bit... Muddled.


i like it and i think it's funny.

ciaralee


quality posts: 2 Private Messages ciaralee
orabbit wrote:I think they meant why does this image exist? What are you trying to say here? Why would Pooh grind up his buddy in the garbage disposal, and how does this relate to the theme?


Yes, you have summed up my meaning quite well.

Mavyn


quality posts: 22 Private Messages Mavyn
plainyoghurt wrote:Is "kid friendly" and "tasteful" part of the submission criteria?


Since Woot sells kid sizes, yes, 'kid friendly' is kind of a thing. Don't know that it's a reason for rejection, but it will cut into votes.

My speech is not parsing. I am speaking in ellipsis.

More Derby Entries

By date:

By rank:

Thumbnail